Progressive taxation is key to delivering health justice in the Commonwealth – say civil society experts

Sierra Leone Telegraph: 29 June 2022:

Public health specialists and advisors to the World Health Organisation, Asian Development Bank and World Bank came together at the Commonwealth People’s Forum in Kigali, Rwanda over a week ago, to discuss how the coalition of 54 Commonwealth member states can advance health justice.

It’s the first time Commonwealth civil society has convened in four years at this scale, owing to the pandemic, with the discussion spanning improving solidarity between Commonwealth countries and pandemic preparedness.

In particular, advocates agreed on next steps for tackling global health emergencies, focusing on progressive taxation as vital to achieving universal health coverage.

Dr Ravi Rannan-Eliya, a Sri Lankan physician and economist and consultant for both the World Bank and Asian Development Bank, said: ‘In most Commonwealth countries, we don’t have insurance, we rely on taxation.…We have to get the well-off to pay more in taxes…And you can’t build resilient health systems unless you use public financing. That means government taxation or mandatory social insurance, which requires government intervention. Why is this a solidarity issue? It’s a solidarity issue because both those things require you to take money from the better off to provide services for the vulnerable.’

Dr Justice Koonin, Australian HIV advocate and co-chair of the Universal Health Coverage 2030 campaign group, agreed and added that civil society must play an advocacy role to ensure marginalised groups aren’t left behind. ‘There’s a statement in the 2019 WHO declaration calling for all governments to increase public health spending on primary health care by 1% of GDP — that’s the bare minimum. And this must be achieved through progressive taxation. It’s difficult politically, but that’s why civil society needs to be there. Because universal health coverage isn’t universal health coverage if it doesn’t apply to prisoners and refugees, if we’re not talking about LGBT people. If we provide health care services to everyone else, but not those people, that’s not universal health coverage,’ he said.

Professor Senait Fisseha, Chief Advisor to the WHO Director-General, world-renowned physician and leader in reproductive health and rights from Ethiopia, explained what’s at stake if public financing of healthcare systems isn’t prioritised in the Commonwealth: ‘The global system failed people, especially vulnerable marginalised communities. People in sub-Saharan Africa were scrambling for vaccines. So governments do need to prioritise healthcare investments. The Abuja declaration was for African nations to increase 15% of our GDP into health. Only two countries in sub-Saharan Africa, Rwanda and South Africa, have done that. Many of us are investing very small amounts. So there’s a question of how do we increase domestic resources to ensure we have a very strong primary health care system.’

Dr Ravi Rannan-Eliya gave an example of how to achieve this, citing an example of when the UK public resoundingly supported higher taxation to make their National Health System stronger, in the midst of a global recession and at a time when spending was frozen. He adds this was driven by civil society — with the British Medical Association and other health unions undertaking strategic polling of voters and taking this evidence to the UK government.

‘Healthcare spending was the only item of the budget that was increased [by the UK government] at that time. So this is an example of civil society at its best. That’s what I would call for in your own country.’

About the Commonwealth Foundation

We’re the Commonwealth’s agency for civil society and the issues that matter to 2.5 billion Commonwealth citizens. We strengthen people’s participation in all aspects of public dialogue to promote equal, just and inclusive societies across the Commonwealth’s 54 Member States.

About the Commonwealth People’s Forum

The People’s Forum brings together diverse perspectives to tackle the issues that matter most to the 2.5 billion people in the Commonwealth. Held every two years in the run up to the Commonwealth Heads of Government meeting, the forum is the only gathering of its kind for civil society to exchange ideas on how we transform the systems and attitudes that marginalise so many. The outcomes from the People’s Forum will be shared at a special meeting between Commonwealth Foreign Ministers that takes place later this week at CHOGM in Kigali.

About the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting (CHOGM)

CHOGM is the ultimate decision-making summit of Commonwealth leaders from around the world. Outside of the United Nations, it is the largest international forum bringing together countries from differing points on the development spectrum — including some of the world’s richest nations to many of its poorest. The summit is an opportunity to strengthen the sense of the Commonwealth as a powerful force for global solidarity on issues needing collective action.


Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.