The Yumkella conundrum – Will he stay with NGC or return to SLPP?

Abdulai Mansaray: Sierra Leone Telegraph: 6 March 2021:

Two weeks ago, President Bio extended an olive branch to Dr Kandeh Yumkella, the figure head of the National Grand Coalition (NGC) party, while visiting Samu chiefdom in the Kambia district – the political heartland of Kandeh Yumkella’s political party, where all of the district’s parliamentarians are NGC politicians.

In reply to President Bio’s request for Kandeh Yumkella to return to the ruling SLPP party, Dr Yumkella said: “Ar hold word” a Krio phrase – meaning ‘I will think about it’ .

This is what Dr Yumkella said in an attempt to clarify what he said to the President, in response to the confusion expressed on social media by many, including his supporters, after his meeting with the President:  “Salaam All, I joined our elders in Kychom to receive the President in Kychom today. The President in his speech presented Kola and Bora asking me to return to the SLPP. I responded that I was there to respect the institution of the presidency and to demonstrate that though we are from different political parties, we as a constructive opposition we want Salone to better. Concerning his specific request and Bora, I thanked him for the gesture and respect and “AHH Hole Word”.”

Many regard Kandeh Yumkella’s reply as a diplomatic rebuff of the President’s request for Yumkella to return to his late father’s party. But speculation had been rife. Many had expected Kandeh Yumkella to accept the invite from the President to return to the SLPP.

Yumkella’s reply – “Ar hold word”, has also been interpreted by many as Dr Yumkella leaving the door open for his eventual return to the ruling SLPP, prompting Dr. Dennis Bright, Chairman and Leader of the NGC Party to publish this statement:

“The attention of the leadership of the NGC has been drawn to several postings in the social media indicating that our Parliamentary leader and former flag bearer, the Hon. Dr. Kandeh Kolleh Yumkella has crossed or is on the verge of crossing over to join the ruling SLPP party. As Chairman of NGC I would like the world to know that this is not only far from the truth but is impossible. We in NGC have high values and principles that guide our actions and we do not succumb to either baits or threats. We thank his Excellency for thinking that KKY has some value and that his party wants him. But we are sorry that he is not available for cross-over transactions. Let us enjoy our democracy. KKY is not going to SLPP. He will maintain the excellent relationship he has nurtured over the years with good people in the SLPP, APC,NGC and all the other political parties. But he remains committed to his party, and will follow the direction that his party decides”.

In order to understand this political gymnastics, we might benefit from looking at why Kandeh Yumkella left the SLPP and formed the NGC in the first place. Was he pushed? Did he jump?

The circumstances leading to Kandeh Yumkella leaving the SLPP are well documented. We all saw how the SLPP fought tooth and nail to close the door in his face. His membership to SLPP was questioned and disqualified. His contribution to the party and even Sierra Leone was scrutinised, thanks to his long sojourn in the international arena.

Many described Yumkella as Missing in Action (MIA) when the SLPP was in its political wilderness. Every roadblock was erected along his path to his political roadmap. His crime? For having the audacity to vie for the ultimate position of SLPP flagbearer.

What KKY (as he is fondly known) did not count on was Presidents Bio’s lifelong ambition to lead Sierra Leone. Since President Bio gave up power after the Strasser palace coup, which earned him the fond name of “father of democracy” to his supporters, his dream of signing a tenancy agreement for State House became a vocation.

And so, for KKY to come from “nowhere” and aim for the top was considered treasonable on SLPP terms. With President Bio’s faction of the SLPP (known as the Paopa brigade) in situ, it was inevitable that KKY would not find a political home or space in the SLPP, if his eyes were only the main prize. KKY had no option but to leave, giving birth to the National Grand Coalition Party.

So, why did KKY leave the SLPP?

Did KKY leave the SLPP on matters of principle? Were there political or policy differences? No. KKY left because his political ambition to lead the SLPP was not accommodated. Would you say he left for personal reasons or for national considerations? Don’t answer that. Since the formation of the NGC, many have regarded it as a “protest party” hence commonly referred to as the KKY movement.

But NGC is a party and not a movement. It takes its “movement” flavour, thanks to the whirlwind nature of its popularity. So even when KKY sought solace in his newly formed party, little did he know that the ruling APC party had more in store for him.

While the SLPP barred him from party membership, the APC launched a Putin like political missile to stop him, not only from contesting the election but also from being a citizen of Sierra Leone. The APC is still counting its losses for such a misguided attempt.

Ironically, the APC “two sim” saga brough KKY and the NGC to such political prominence that allowed Bio and the SLPP to sneak in undetected in 2018 elections. The rest is history.

With this backdrop, was KKY going to accept President Bio’s offer of an olive branch?

I believe that KKY would look to his partner in distress, Sam Sumana and do the prodigal son. Like KKY, Sam was literally booted out of the APC. Unlike KKY, Sam took a whole district out of the lap of the APC, thanks to tribal and regional sentiments.

Interestingly, Sam may believe that any hope of leading this country could lie with one of the two political parties. He has gambled on this notion, abandoned his baby project the C4C, giving credence to the notion that his party was conceived from the womb of a protest.

Like KKY, Sam did not leave the APC on a matter of principle or policy differences. Both were kicked out and both became midwives of their respective “protest parties”. Many Sierra Leoneans flocked to these two for various reasons, ranging from regional, tribal or other reasons. But the undercurrent reason reflected how bored, tired, disillusioned and fed up the nation felt about these two political parties.

Many Sierra Leoneans seemed to just want a change from the same humdrum mantra and were desperately seeking a third way.

Was KKY right to reject Bio’s overtures?

While many of Bio’s supporters see his invitation to KKY as a mark of statesmanship, others have concluded that the SLPP is pushing the panic button. If the latter is anything to go by, is Maada making the same mistake as EBK?

On the other hand, some will see Bio’s move as one of political expediency to nullify a voter distraction. Sadly, and regrettably, revenge politics has become a common feature of Sierra Leone’s political landscape.

By rejecting Bio’s invitation, has KKY pushed the revenge button?

Like him or loathe him, KKY is a political asset to Sierra Leone. KKY may not have been a household name prior to 2018, but his CV reads well for a country like ours. As a former Chairman of the UN-Energy and two-term former Director -General of the United Nations Industrial Organisation (UNIDO) he comes with a wealth of knowledge and experience as a distinguished development economist and expert in agricultural economics.

He has won numerous awards including 2015 Development Award (Brussels), United Nations Association (UNA-USA) Global Leadership Award, 2012 Energy Efficiency Visionary Award, and many more. Yumkella believes that “the most effective way to fight poverty is to strengthen the productive capacities of countries and peoples”. There is your prescription for a failed country.

Can you begin to imagine how Sierra Leone could benefit from such a reservoir and wealth of knowledge, experience and global connections?

Yumkella has a better world view of what Africa needs to develop, not to talk about Sierra Leone. Would Sierra Leone be best served by Yumkella from the position of a bridesmaid of a political party or from within one of the main parties? Should KKY re-join the SLPP in the interest of the country? Did KKY leave SLPP and rejected the invitation for personal reasons? Irrespective of your views, Bio’s invitation has generated a political maelstrom in many circles. Whether this will dominate the conversation just like in 2018, is anyone’s guess.

So, has KKY made a wise decision? Would he effect the much-desired developmental change from the chambers of a political bridesmaid or from within the SLPP bowels of power? Should he had re-joined the SLPP? Would he suffer the same fate as the orphan politician Sam Sumana? Was KKY right to pass on this opportunity, or is it a case of “better a king in hell than a slave in heaven”? Only time will tell.

If you ask me, KKY would have served Sierra Leone, not SLPP better from within. While some see politics as the art of making one’s selfish desires seem like the national interest, others believe that there are no principles in politics, just opportunities.

Has KKY passed on the opportunity or stuck to his principles? Some men change their party for the sake of their principles, others their principles for the sake of their party (Churchill). Which option has KKY taken?

Since most political differences depend on disagreements in moral principles, is KKY insisting on agreement with his political principles or engaged in “you do me Ar do you?”

2023, where are you? Don’t forget to turn the lights out when you leave the room.

You can watch the followinhg videos and make up your own minds:

 

3 Comments

  1. S.M.OG. save me o God, some people even gave another meaning to it saying” samuel madunka obi”. Dr. Yumkella is nothing but a brilliant, smart and eloquent professor, that who he is. I tried to find someone to make a translation for me from that beautiful SUSU language saying” wun barameh”, meaning we hold word. Dr. Yumkella will returns back to his late father’s club if at all he is destine to rule this country one day. In the late 2018 presidential election; APC painted him with all colors and even pushed him to the extend to strip himself from U.S. Citizenship. All these parties depending the Diasporas donations, but APC party totally denied them not to contest for any office in the country, I hope you still remember that. SLPP is your house, come back they need you badly right now, let no one fools you nobody likes you period. Bio is the best politician, and his victory on the way comes 2023. I will vote for him again because he deserved my vote. Later

  2. Nothing but DESPERATION at work here! Barely a year to general elections, Bio and his gang of thieves are suddenly undergoing a metamorphosis—transforming from an exclusively PAOPA regiment’s club in running the affairs of the state, to now extending an olive branch to an individual, considered all along as an existential threat to the very foundation of the PAOPA mantra, and tireless efforts has been made to completely annihilated him.

    If KKY wants to depreciate his relevancy within the politics of our nation, or, have aims and objectives to corruptly enrich himself like the corrupt bunch, then he will be just fine, and should swallow the bait. Else, I guarantee you, he will be used and dumped like a toilet tissue by the PAOPA regiment, factoring this might be the second and final chance of them getting super rich at the backs of the suffering masses.

  3. Perhaps we should guard against reading too much into Bio’s attempt to lure Dr Yumkella back to the SLPP fold. The NGC Parliamentary Leader’s response to the President’s overtures of peace and reconciliation was that he was going to think things through. That may well have meant no, diplomatically.

    It seems to me that Paopa apologists have tended to blow the whole event out of proportion on social media. And predictably so. They have quite simply been pushing a political line. This is because the general and presidential election is barely a year away. As a result of this, the Paopa propaganda machine has swung into action. It has perhaps gone into overdrive and may already be firing on all cylinders. This means that it will seize on anything and make political capital out of it.

    Dr Bright and the rest of the NGC leadership including Dr Yumkella himself cannot be easily conned. As a matter of fact, you do not have to be a genius to realise that Bio’s fence mending operation may well be a cynical ploy aimed at neutralising a political party whose performance in the forthcoming election could potentially cost him and his party a second five-year term that they are hell bent on securing. What they have failed to ask themselves though is this: what will Dr Yumkella be going back to? To share in the Paopa regime’s inglorious and grossly inept performance in office? To extend for five more years its egregiously corrupt, largely ethnicist and so nationally ruinous mode of governance?

    President Bio, please give Dr Yumkella and his party a break.

Tell us what you think

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.